I don't have time right now to give actual measurements but hopefully I can offer some insight. According to ETKA, the crank sprocket for the 1Z/AHU TDI (028 105 263E) is a *different part number* from the ALH sprocket (038 105 263 E). In your PM you mention that you got the later one. I have not gotten one of the ALH ones, so I can't confirm that the difference lies there, but I can say for certain that the 1.6TD, 1.9TD (AAZ), and the 1Z/AHU (96-98 TDI) are all the SAME crank nose diameter and the step on the inside of the sprocket matches it. The only explanation I can offer is the possibility that the ALH crank nose is a larger diameter and you got the ALH sprocket instead of the 1Z/AHU one.
opps sorry bout the caps wasnt yelling lol, but if you want it send me a text tomorrow evening, im working during the day but ya ill be around after 5.....
...BTW your Bieber avatar is awesome.-Malone