i'm not a vw expert, but i thought TDI's have 20mm shafts, i believe late TD's also. TDI's have an other profile camplate, i dont know you can become the same pressure rate with a TD camplate in a TDI.
On the rear side of the camplate you have the 2 pins, i think the 20mm pumps got a other offset than the 17mmshaft-pump camplate's.
i ever had a 'newer' camplate in my 'old' pump, it was my first plungerswap, when the pump was mounted on the engine it was ticking loud, much heat (watertemp), much smoke, and very bad running was the problem.
Anyway, who want this 12mm plunger

is the price to high or is there just no intrests???
Greetz, Benjamin