This isn't a good faq question, so I am moving it to IDI. At any rate Oils aren't what they used to be.
Main question is not being asked, what condition is the engine? New 0 mile or 500,000 or somewhere in between. You Do Not run a syth or blended synth on a new engine from 84. IMHO syth is not a great choice for the 500,000 oil if it hasn't seen it all its life as it will cause most seals to leak as they are not used to the detergents in syth. For break in new engine I like the Rotella T3 10w30 or Brad Penn 10w-30-both are diesel rated.
Most all big manufactures of oil are not what they used to be. Pennzoil, quaker state, wolfs head, valvoline, and more are NOT using Pennsylvania crude oil as a base. They are using saudi oil for a base which is lighter and doesn't have the zinc content that penn. crude does. For conventional oil BRAD PENN is the only oil I have found that the base oil is pulled from Bradford, Penn. The stuff is a bit green going in. The Brad Penn and Rotella are the only oils I will use *t3 is the rotella that is conventional* For sythetic most all are pretty good at adding what is needed, but Schaeffer's adds the zinc and it is a greenish color as well. I can buy the Schaeffer's oil for 22.00 ish / gallon for the full synthetic 9000 series and something like 18.00/ gallon for the 7000 semi sythetic. With that you get FREE oil analysis when using their oil, shipping and all. They make a great product, and the only one I will use currently. Amsoil is ok, but the rep couldn't tell me where the base stock they get comes from, and never came around again to let me know.
Recap: Rotella, Brad Penn, Schaeffer's diesel rated oil that is all I use.