I have 13 Optimas in use, some for over ten years. Really like the no corrosion feature. As acid batteries fail, I AGM the equipment.
Have lost one; it was 10 years old, still charges up, but droops below 70% overnight with terminals disconnected. Will start a car still, but not dependable. I use it to run my fuel tank pump still.
Thats a pretty good record.
I bought an Oddessy 2250, and sent it back for warranty after 8 months, but started discussion warranty exchange at 5 months, and there was no cold weather involved. The reason I sent it back, was when charging at 13.4V, it boiled acid out of two cells, which is not supposed to happen. I have not had that issue with Optimas.
The biggest problem I have seen with AGM batteries is learning how to charge them or people not understanding how to charge them. I have drained them to zero, put a charger on them and it kicks out saying "bad". Simply disconnect terminals, charge again, repeatedly bringing it back up about 20% each time. Once at 70%, Optimas will charge right up and be a good battery again. Fully drained AGM charge best on digital chargers compatible with AGM vs alternator. Once at 70%, or even at 50% any 12v-14VDC source is good.
Since all my Autos are nearly 20 years or older, as well my tractors, I do not like to replace battery trays, etc.
I have 16 diesel vehicles or diesel equipment to service, and the time saved from cleaning terminals amounts up. Not cleaning terminal in 5 or more years is valuable time saved.
For people who don't keep an auto over 5-8 years, I do not suggest them. For me on my farm, they are great.
Wayne