Okay, well running a wire with a lamp from another cluster inline, I couldn't get the alternator to excite.
I'm pretty sure the alternator was charging before the swap. Could hooking up the W and D+ together have damaged something inside the alternator? The normal blue exciter wire seems to be funtioning fine.
Also, I've read about putting a diode inline from B+ to D+ should cause the alternator to charge.. to test this does anyone know which way the diode should point?
Edit: Well, I checked for voltage while the car was running at D+ and W and there is 0.4V - 0.5V coming out of both, that number seems awefully low to me, thinking my problem is the alternator. Getting another this afternoon, will test with that.