Like I said in your other thread, I think your piston melted from having the valve leak out the boost air resulting in an over-fueled situation with piston melting temps. Unfortunately if it's an exhaust valve leaking, an EGT will still register normal in this situation because the leaked air cools the exhaust stream resulting in normal or even low EGTs.
15 psi will result in cooler temps than stock boost of 9 or 10. Upping the fuel a little didn't melt that piston unless you were seeing a fair bit of smoke.
I didn't see smoke during the long climb but to be honest, I wasn't looking for it.
I have been reading the FAQ and chasing threads on this site for hours and hours trying to get a "feel" for this motor and it's quirky nuances. I really want this re-build to be strong and dependable - now I'm having serious doubts that it's even possible. From what you are saying, I can burn a piston because the gate on the turbo is leaking?(if that is the "valve you are referring to). That installing an EGT won't tell me that anything is happening? -man that really has me worried. I took the valve out and the seat was coked up but nothing like others I have seen.
I removed all the carbon from the port seat and did the polish thing that was suggested in the FAQ. However, I don't think it's going to seal perfectly as the surface is pitted a bit. I had it set up in my mill and was going to try a spot-face but decided the casting was too hard and I may just mess it up. The bevel of the valve is 22.5 degrees BTW.
The rod on the valve was sticky when I pushed it in - could this be part of the issue? Pushing it an while turning the valve seems to have freed it up nicely. If what you say is true, having to rebuild this motor because the valve on the turbo leaked boost is pretty crappy design don't you think? Any suggestion as to how to make this not happen again? From what I have read, this is a pretty good turbo for my application - maybe I should switch to a VNT? I will be adding an intercooler from Frozen Boost and an external oil cooler as well but that's just an expensive band-aid if I have a leaky valve.
OK, I found your post from the previous thread - sorry I misread your meaning of "valve" and just started rambling on about the waste-gate
Another possibility is that the exhaust or intake valve on that cylinder leaked and let out the boost air. The resulting over-fueled situation got the piston too hot and it started to melt. That would be pretty easy to check. Tip the head on it's side with the ports up and pour/spray some solvent in there. If it leaks out on the combustion face, your valves were leaking. Any impressions on the piston tops?
You were talking about an intake valve leaking and I didn't find that to be the case after doing the "leak-test" you suggested. I did find quite a bit of burnt crud on all the intake ports though which I still don't understand - as it makes me think
all the intake valves were "leaking". Is this possible? - Possibly a timing issue?
I my have mentioned this in one of my earlier posts - when I took off the intake manifold, every bolt was just slightly over finger tight. This could certainly "dump" boost and prevent it from providing the cooling effect you mention.
What do you think of the numbers from the engine and crank? If this was yours, would you bore and grind?