I beleive they are the same made by Sanden. I replaced the one on my 16V gasser with one from a G60 corrado so I could run a serpentine belt and it fit fine. (it was originally a 8V gasser). I'm 90% sure they are the same, I'm thinking at least from years 88-92. I'm not so sure before then. However the 96' MK3 compresser also looks the same. I think you can use it. I'd be wondering why it broke the tab and is shedding bolts before I put a different one on? Is the bracket possibly bent or broken. I never did like the setup the MK2 had for the alternator and AC compressor.Just my $.02