i have an 83 rabbit with mechanical gauges, the temp is very eradic, it will rise to 230 then fall down to the opperating temp of 190, the time it takes to drop is never the same, some times a few seconds, other times i have to pull over and kick the heater on full bore to get it to cool down. the thermostat is fine, it is the second one, i changed it just to be safe. i tested the old one in a hot plate of water and it opened fine, and at the right temps, when it started doing the same thing with the new stat, i pulled it and it works fine on the bench. but the engine still gets hot, the radiator was new last winter, the coolant system is not getting over-pressurized, and i am not mixing oil and coolant, so i think the head gasket is ok. the water pump seems to be fine, there is a constant flow of coolant out of the radiator overflow tube to the reservoir. also, i know the gauge is reading right i checked it with an ifared thermometer. when the engine is at 200, according to the thermometer the thermostat is closed, the lower hose is about 70 where above the t-state is 195 or more. how could a stat work in a pan of water but not in the engine, am i over looking somthing? any help would be great, oh by the way the pump and injectors are fresh rebuilt with all the fuel put to it that i can get and still get it to idle, I LIKE SMOKE!!!! but i have had other cars that were turned up and never got hot.