I am consistently getting 48-52mpg from the turbocharged '83 1.6 engine with a solid lifter head and NA IP in my '92 MKII Jetta. The engine is from a NA MK1 Rabbit.
After the timing belt broke in my '92 ECO diesel due to a seized tension pulley I decided to swap in the '83 motor instead of rebuilding the ECO engine.
I just swapped over the intake manifold, turbo and exhaust manifold, valve cover, oil filter mount with oil cooler and oil lines to the turbo, oil pan and pickup tube, clutch and flywheel (the clutch from the Rabbit had a broken spring), engine mounts (cut off the MKI passenger side mount), water pump (the MKI pump had a leak), alternator, and a couple of sensors due to different wiring harness plugs from the MKII ECO to the MKI NA motor.
I left the MKI NA injection pump, injectors and glow plugs in place. The only new parts I used were a new timing belt, tensioner pulley, oil pan and valve cover gaskets, plus new oil and filters.
I have over 15,000 miles on the car since the swap. The only problem I had since the swap was with the alternator belt and I solved that by going to a single belt system for the alt. & water pump (power steering and AC have been removed).
It feels like it has more power than the ECO engine plus it gets about five MPG more than ECO engine did.