I installed the dakota digital unit and I had bought the a tach that could read w-terminal as well and didn't know it at the time. I liked the dakota unit better (easier to hook the wires up and didn't have to pull the tack if something is wrong, easier to adjust as well). I bought external digital tach to check it ($30.00 or so). Once set the dakota digital is set, it is very accurate, always comes back to idle exactly as I set it so I assume revs through the range are right. Speeds seem about correct with revs. I have a MK2 jetta with same gearing so rpms are very close to it.
the only problem I have (MK 3 alternator with w) is about 2500 rpm it will flick to full and back to correct rpm a couple times, very quickly. After about 2600 or so it stops and is stable as high as you want to go.