As far as TD power (indirect injection, no computer, like your Jetta) is concerned--there is a MK2 Golf I see around here. The owner (Bill) claims 160hp at the wheels, with propane. So many folks boast about their numbers, so I don't know how accurate this is. This car beats my VR, every time, up to 65/70 mph.
Rennen Performance in Brunswick, Maine did the work on a local MK 4 TDI (direct injection with computer controls), and they claim a corrected chassis dyno figure of 200 hp and over 400 lbs tq--at the wheels. Daily driver. Power all the time, anytime (in the rev range). Monster twist!
My VR makes its power, starting at 3200 rpm--the TDs and TDIs I've driven are ready to shift up around there.
The VR has 20 headbolts (PITA) and requires 6 qts oil per change. The timing chains fail--even the updated single row design with the new style tensioner don't last too long if you hammer on it often (gotta pull the tranny to replace the chains). There are two coolant pumps--one is electric, and is pretty failure prone. Heads suffer from errosion/corrosion issues. The cooling system has quite a bit of plastic that cracks and fails (the VR runs VERY hot--my oil temps range from 220 to 260 with full synthetic oil) due to the high underhood temps. Coil packs (only early, and rare, 92/93 engines have a dizzy and a conventional VW coil) fail often on high rev-ers. Bolted to the side of the head, the heat makes them crack and fail. Etc.
I'm not saying the VR is crap, but from a service viewpoint, the inline 4 VW diesels are a JOY in comparison. And still, can kick arse!
Big fan of Quebec--and Montreal. I spend a few weeks each summer in Montreal/Mont Tremblanc.